Notifications

Clear all

Is Jimmie Johnson the Greatest Ever?

Shadowracer · 2009-10-20T08:24:01Z

From Marty Smith's Column on ESPN.com. Thought it might make some interesting discussion.Article link here.Marty,I saw this week on "NASCAR Now" when you asked [Barney Hall] from MRN where Jimmie Johnson ranked in the all-time greatest drivers. He said one of the best in the past 10 years. Where would you rank Jimmie Johnson among the best Marty? -- Rick King, Tallapoosa, Ala.This answer will be blasphemous to old-school fans who appreciate the hardships the sport's founders endured -- outrunning the law and risking life and limb for pennies -- and detest the money and fame and pampering today's stars enjoy. Ready? Here it is: Jimmie Johnson very well may be the greatest NASCAR driver ever. I can hear the good ol' boys hollerin' down the mountain now: "You dumba--! He's a pretty-boy Jeff Gordon clone who was handed everything! And they're cheaters!" Whatever. What Johnson is doing in the era he's doing it in is nothing short of amazing. It is harder to win right now than it's ever been. By design, the cars are closer than they've ever been. The ebb and flow of excellence is fickle -- last year Carl Edwards won eight races and thus was the championship favorite among 80 percent of the media last February. Edwards hasn't won in 2009. And the 48 continues to maintain an unparalleled performance level.[+] EnlargeAP Photo/Reed SaxonJimmie Johnson has 45 wins in 285 career Cup starts, a winning percentage that ranks among NASCAR's greats.Some of that is Chad Knaus' ability. He is probably the best crew chief ever, though Smokey and Ray Evernham would beg to differ. Some of that is the bottomless financial and technological and engineering pool that Rick Hendrick supplies his teams. But the 24 and the 88 and the 5 have that same pool at their disposal and haven't enjoyed the sustained dominance the 48 has. Johnson's too-perfect polish annoys many fans. It's hard to respect for some, and leads many to misperceive its genuineness and necessity. Johnson came from a humble background. He was raised in a trailer park until he was 8 years old and worked for everything he ever got. Having no money to fund his own effort, he had to be a good spokesperson. He had to be cordial. He had to smile and shake hands and mention sponsors and make darn certain not to ruffle too many feathers.You don't just cut that off -- unless you forget who you are. That approach never abandons you, regardless how much fame and wealth you accumulate. Johnson is becoming more comfortable with speaking out and has begun to accept his place in NASCAR history, though he won't embellish. Few drivers in their prime will do so. I was hanging out with a buddy late Wednesday night, an ol' Earnhardt fan, and between sips of Jack Daniel's we debated Johnson's image. My buddy says he's too pretty, too perfect, too corporate, too New York. Then I told him Johnson will raise hell with the best of them. And that his commitment to excellence is barely rivaled. He doesn't coast. He easily could coast. He has three straight titles and a bushel of wins and a plane and a model wife. So what'd he do? Went out and hired a revered personal trainer and got in the best shape of his life. He's in the gym every day. And his fitness level is ridiculous.One of my favorite television programs -- that just sounded like my 95-year-old grandmother -- is "Around The Horn" on ESPN. Love the banter, especially when my boy Cowlishaw prevails. The other day Jay Mariotti won, and during his final-thought diatribe mentioned that we should pay greater respect to Peyton Manning's ability, that we are witnesses of historic greatness and letting it pass us by with a passing glance. He was talking about Manning. But what I heard was Johnson. The very same principle applies. What Johnson is doing transcends racing. It's sports excellence, not just racing excellence. Richard Petty won 200 races in 1,184 starts, a 17 percent win ratio. David Pearson won 105 races in 574 starts -- 18 percent. Dale Earnhardt earned 76 wins in 676 starts for an 11 percent winning rate. Those three gentlemen are widely regarded as the best three drivers in NASCAR history. By comparison, Johnson has 45 wins in 285 starts, 16 percent. Oh, wait … I hear the good ol' boys hollerin' down the mountain again … "Petty and Pearson and Earnhardt drove crappy cars with no power steering or pretty-boy cool-suits, idiot! And Johnson has always had the best stuff." Yep, that argument gets tossed around a lot. And, yep, Johnson has always had good cars at the Cup level. But it's the consistent excellence that's so striking. He's never been a nonfactor.Jeff Burton made a good point this week: It's nearly impossible to respect an athlete or team's excellence in the moment. The further down the road you get from those perfor...

Page 2 / 7 Prev Next

Last Post

RSS

Posts: 21343

CanadianRacingOnline

Admin

Nov 15, 2009 6:45 pm

(@canadianracingonline)

Member

Joined: 23 years ago

Missed this topic but I will say that it's so hard to rate Jimmy as the best as the Chase changed the whole way champions are crowned. So I would say Jimmy is the best driver so far as the Chase Champions go.

Someone mention that Dale Jr could win like Jimmy with Chad Knaus. Nope Dale JR is not a great driver. Sorry Jr fans but it's the truth.

Canadian Racing Archive Project.
http://www.canadianracingarchives.com/

Posts: 0

mike32

Nov 15, 2009 6:50 pm

(@mike32)

Joined: 1 second ago

not the greatest as he has no personality. He is the whitebread of motorsports.

Posts: 3382

Thayne

Nov 15, 2009 7:30 pm

(@barrie97ps)

Famed Member

Joined: 20 years ago

This is the way I go about it. He is the best of this era, but just like int he other sports, you can never really know if he was the best ever.....

Gretzky vs. Orr
Jordan Vs. Bird/Magic/Lebron?
Petty vs. earnhardt vs. gordon vs. johnson tough

Posts: 21343

CanadianRacingOnline

Admin

Nov 15, 2009 8:11 pm

(@canadianracingonline)

Member

Joined: 23 years ago

Hockey still has the same playoff format as does basket ball. Nascar changed the way they crowned the champion. I guess the era thing makes more sense but try to get these guys that report on Nascar to say it that way.

Canadian Racing Archive Project.
http://www.canadianracingarchives.com/

Posts: 0

thecrowdpleaser

Nov 15, 2009 8:54 pm

(@thecrowdpleaser)

Joined: 1 second ago

Don't forget that if the old points system had of been in place, Jeff Gordon would have won two of Jimmies' championships. Giving Jeff 6 championships, and Jimmie 2...............then there's no argument at all.............aside from trying to figure out if Jeff is the best ever, and if he can win 7 or more. Keep it in perspective.

Page 2 / 7 Prev Next

Forum Statistics

95 Forums

25.6 K Topics

91.4 K Posts

11 Online

22 Members

Latest Post: New One Day Saturday Showcase for the Northeast Classic at New Hampshire Motor Speedway Our newest member: racer61 Recent Posts Unread Posts Tags

Forum Icons: Forum contains no unread posts Forum contains unread posts

Topic Icons: Not Replied Replied Active Hot Sticky Unapproved Solved Private Closed